Cake Decorating Blog

Man About Cake Needs Your Vote! Meet the #MACFanChallenge Finalists

We asked you to send in sketches of your craziest cake ideas to help us celebrate the very first anniversary of Man About Cake. Well, the sketches are in! And things are looking… sweet.

Hundreds of you participated in the #MACFanChallenge, and now our Caked Crusader needs your help narrowing it down from his Top 5. (After all, we’d never be here if it wasn’t for all of you!)

The winning cake slayer will have their design made by Joshua on Man About Cake Season 7, and receive a special mystery prize package from JJR and the crew.

Vote for your favorite below (and don’t forget to tune in on YouTube for new episodes starting 9/19!).

Meet our 5 finalists

#macfanchallenge Margarita flavoured desert cake!

A post shared by quirkman (@quirkman) on

#macfanchallenge

A post shared by AwkwardArtist87 (@awkwardartist87) on

Check out ALL the incredible #MACFanChallenge creations here!

Please note: The deadline to vote for your favorite cake design is October 1, 2017, at 11:59 p.m. MT. The winner will be notified via email, and Joshua will reveal the winning design on Season 7 of Man About Cake.

Can’t wait to catch Joshua and the boys back in action? Brush up by binge-watching the first five seasons! (You know you want to.)

Explore the Episodes

112 Comments

Anisha Gupta

Bonsai for me too!

Reply
Renee

Me too! Love trees on anything…

Reply
Sophia

I love the tree cake

Reply
Soph

Mine is for the Bonsai cake too!

Reply
Purebredmutt

I adore 4 out of the 5 of them! How am I supposed to vote? Oh well. Better too many options than too few!

Reply
Robin Smith

Bonsai for me, too.

Reply
Hafsa Zoya

Bonsai for me as well

Reply
Kris

Choosing the bonsai cake was not an easy choice, but believe it will give Joshua the greatest challenge in terms of engineering the cake to handle the heavy load at the top of the cake. I would actually choose the butterfly cake as a cake I would purchase as Daniflavored has a wonderful eye in design and color – “WOW” was the word used at its first sight.

Reply
Anita Outlaw

Totally agree with Kris!! All designs were amazing!! What fun!!!

Reply
Hillary.Noel

I agree completely!! I chose the bonsai cake as well that butterfly cake though…. I’m floored!

Reply
Maggie

I loke the cactus cake. So cool

Reply
Emilee Manley

Bonsai cake!

Reply
Ameena

I am not sure how to vote. But I vote for garbage cake

Reply
Brie

Me too! It fits in so well, I laugh every time he calls the scraps garbage cake πŸ˜‚

Reply
Toni Darling

Bonsai cake!
They all look fantastic! What a tough decision.

Reply
Brenda

Butterfly cake!

Reply
Corinne D.

The Bonsai Cake is my choice, too.

Reply
Cindi Greear

The monarch butterfly cake.

Reply
dk

Bonsai cake

Reply
Francine- The Garden Baker

I vote for the Bonsai cause I would like to see Joshua’s take on the structure, but I completely agree with Kris. I love the design on the Butterfly Cake. Hey, Josh, how about making 2 cakes: a winner and a runner up??

Reply
Ana Espinal

I vote for the Bonsai Cake!

Reply
Ali hebdala

Simple I vote for the bonsai cake 🌳🌳🌳

Reply
Fiona

Bonsai Cake for sure it is beautiful!

Reply
Avis T.

Bonsai cake

Reply
Michelle Noble

They are all pretty cool. But I vote Bonsai too.

Reply
KW

Butterfly is my favorite with crayon a lose second

Reply
Janet B

Love them all!! However, Bonsai it is……followed closely by Butterfly & Garbage Cake.

Reply
Claudia

Bonsai cake

Reply
Nancy

I would love to see you create the bonsai cake.

Reply
allison angstrom

I would love to see the bonsai cake be made.

Reply
CLK

Bonsai!!!

Reply
Lori

Bonsai cake too

Reply
Christine

Bonsai cake please!!!

Reply
Julie

cactus cake!!

Reply
Karen

I vote for number 4

Reply
Keren

I like the Bonsai Cake

Reply
Angie

bonsai cake

Reply
Erica

Bonsai cake! 😍

Reply
paokho

garbage cake please

Reply
Lourdes

BONSAI πŸ™‚

Reply
Kuzuryu

Bonsai cake !!!

Reply
Sahar

Bonsai Cake!

Reply
Bunnie Hake

I definitely think the bonsai cake would be the most challenging but the butterfly cake is gorgeous!

Reply
Tanner

I like all the ideas. But to vote on just one is difficult to do. I’d say butterfly and bonsai are the top two. But the garbage cake and the margarita cake a close 3rd. The crayon one would be a fun one to do as well. How about he dose all of them. For me it’s a toss up between Butterfly and Bonsai.

Reply
Kim G

Bonsai cake

Reply
Pixe

Bonsai cake

Reply
Γ…sa

The bonsai cake πŸ™‚

Reply
Emma

daniel_emanuelles bonsai cake gets my vote!

Reply
Pauline

Love the butterfly cake! with adding Josh’s creative touch will look amazing!

Reply
Sofia Montoya

My vote is the bonsai it’s so pretty

Reply
Moopsee

Bonsai cake also — way unique!

Reply
Mary

Bonsai cake!!

Reply
Fiore

The BONSAI, Hope this is the vote.

Reply
claud

definitely the bonsai cake

Reply
Tina Murphey

My favorite is the Bonsai Tree cake. I like them all.but I would especially enjoy seeing Josh’s take on how to create the beautiful and exquisite Bonsai tree and have it growing right through the cake!!! That would be Awesome!!! I vote for the Bonsai Cake!

Reply
Dawn

Bonsai. They are all beautiful and fun, but I think the bonsai would give you more of a challenge and I think that’s right up your alley. Whichever one you choose, I know we will all love. 😊

Reply
Camille P

bonsai cake!!! Stunning! I hope you make that one!

Reply
Kate

Bonsai!

Reply
Meggan A

Cactus cake looks like a lot of fun popping colors; that’s my favorite. But I totally see JJR making all 5 on future MACisodes. I’m excited to see which one he chooses!

Reply
Theresa

I love tree’s and nature so would really like to see the bonsai tree

Reply
Cary Williams

The bonsai cake, but the butterfly as a second place

Reply
Corin

Bonsai Tree Cake

Reply
Corin

I’d like to see you make “The Kremlin” out of cake!!

Reply
Carrie Wetzel

Garbage cake! It is fun, lots of detail and you can eat all of it!

Reply
Mai

Bonsai cake!

Reply
Sie

the tree one! its so amazing, plus watching you guys try to figure how to build that will be funny

Reply
Wendy Womyn

Bonsai cake…I think that would look amazing…and maybe a great challenge πŸ™‚

Reply
Jill Hager

Bonsai cake!

Reply
Kalyn Mallard

Torn between two cakes to vote on. Finally picked one.

Reply
Annette Pearce

I would love to see Joshua make the bonsai cake.

Reply
Jho

They are all great contenders but my vote is for the bonsai cake πŸ™‚

Reply
Olivia

I love the detail in the bonsai cake but the garbage cake is much more fitting for the show. Can you do both?!! πŸ˜‚

Reply
Phil

Bonsai!

Reply
Darlou

Bonsai cake! Please!?

Reply
Gorgo

Bonsai cake.

Reply
Sherryann

Bonsai cake with the butterfly coming in a close second. #voting#MAC#loveyourshow.

Reply
Sam

Butterfly cake please

Reply
Ella Bailey

I agree with you Sam the butterfly cake should be chosen!!!!!!

Reply
Jade

Bonsai cake please!!! Your cakes are amazing!

Reply
Orianna

Garbage cake!! It would fit in very well!! Love the little monsters to so awesome!

Reply
Anonymous

Bonsai!!!!!

Reply
Clarissa

Totally the Bonsai! It’s AWESOME!

Reply
Mra

Bonsai cake please!

Reply
Tina

Bonsai cake 🍰

Reply
Mimsy

Oh well, it’s really hard to choose but I choose Bonsai too!! all of them are cute tho β™‘

Reply
Yuliana

Bonsai cake

Reply
Pam

Bonsai!

Reply
josefina

Bonsai, please.

Reply
Esther

Bonsai, of course!!!

Reply
Shelly Guevara

Bonsai

Reply
Ella Bailey

The butterfly cake it has my style of different designs and it looks great and it’s amazing!!!!!!

Reply
Katie

I wanted to vote for the bonsai, but accidentally clicked the trash can and it won’t let me switch it… πŸ™

Reply
Christina

Butterfly cake! Bonsai is a close second

Reply
Meg

My vote is for the bonsai tree design

Reply
Brittany Seidenstricker

Bonsai!a

Reply
Shirley Fulton

Bonsai

Reply
Steve Morris

It was a toss up. The cactus Margarita cake or the Bonsai cake! I know how about the Bonsai with Liquor? We love the liquor Chocolate Amaretto! πŸ₯ƒπŸ˜³πŸ˜ŽπŸŽΆ

Reply
AJ

Bonsai cake! Looks amazing and will present a very unique challenge with the structure.

Reply
Diana

I love the Bonsai cake! Go for it Josh πŸ˜€

Reply
Colleen Serra

Bonsai!!

Reply
Anjali Koshy

Bonsai cake!!

Reply
Kerrie

Bonsai cake

Reply
Terri Burke

I vote for the Bonsai cake because I just can’t figure out how you would do it ( even though I also love the design of the butterfly cake)

Reply
Salvador

Bonsai Cake!

Reply
kristen

Gargbage cake!!

Reply
Leslie

Bonsai Cake

Reply
Nancy Brisson

The BonsaΓ― cake because it is up to your talent!

Reply
ayah

the bonsai cake!!!

Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Leave a Reply